Activism
/
September 11, 2024
The Biden administration made clear that the homicide of an American calls for a response—except that American is killed within the West Financial institution by the Israel Protection Forces.
Crowds commemorate Aysenur Ezgi Eygi in Oakland, California, on September 9, 2024, after Israeli troopers shot her within the head within the West Financial institution as she was standing in solidarity with the Palestinian individuals.
(Tayfun Coskun / Anadolu by way of Getty Photos)
In February, after three US troops have been killed in a drone strike in Jordan, President Joe Biden issued a warning. “America doesn’t search battle within the Center East or wherever else on this planet. However let all those that may search to do us hurt know this: In the event you hurt an American, we are going to reply.”
The household of Ayşenur Eygi may beg to vary.
Present Concern
Final week, Eygi, a 26-year-old American citizen, was fatally shot within the head throughout an indication towards unlawful settlements within the occupied West Financial institution. A number of eyewitnesses informed reporters that Israeli troopers assassinated her as she stood within the rear of the protest.
“It was a direct shot to the pinnacle, it was not an accident,” one witness informed Haaretz. “She was being additional protected out of the entire volunteers, she and her pals have been standing the furthest again, within the most secure spot that we thought.” One other witness informed the paper, “We have been seen to the military, simply standing round not doing something. Nothing was taking place. I heard two dwell pictures—one hit a steel object after which a Palestinian and injured him within the leg after which one second after I turned and I noticed [Eygi] laying unconscious on the bottom.”
The homicide of an American isn’t any roughly tragic than the homicide of some other human being. However American deaths sometimes obtain outsize consideration from politicians and the press. In different circumstances, you’d count on the execution of a peaceable American protester to attract outrage from the US president. But, as of this writing, Biden has made no public assertion about Eygi’s killing. Nor has Vice President Kamala Harris. Nor has both of them contacted Eygi’s household. The truth is, it took 4 days for a senior Biden administration official to supply any condemnation of her dying.
America will not be within the behavior of permitting different international locations to homicide its personal residents. However Eygi’s killing seems to have rendered probably the most highly effective nation on earth a helpless bystander, keen to outsource its response to Israel.
“Our companions in Israel have indicated that they’re conducting a course of and that they may make public their findings,” State Division spokesperson Vedant Patel informed reporters on Monday, declining to vow that the US would examine by itself. He additionally made clear that Israel would get the good thing about the doubt as to what precisely had occurred, although Israel has an extended historical past of mendacity about its troopers. “Any time an American citizen or civilian loses their life, it’s extremely tragic. However the circumstances round how that occurs is vital,” he stated.
“In the event you hurt an American, we are going to reply” has morphed into “In the event you hurt an American, we are going to repeatedly cite one other nation’s investigation and insinuate that the homicide was justified.” The conclusion to attract is evident: The dying of an American calls for a right away, forceful response—except that American is killed by Israelis whereas protesting on behalf of Palestinian rights.
It’s hardly the primary time america has engaged in such double requirements. In 2022, Israeli snipers assassinated Shireen Abu Akleh, a US citizen working for Al Jazeera within the West Financial institution, whereas she was carrying a press vest. Each obtainable piece of proof means that Israeli forces focused her. The Biden administration primarily ignored her dying. No American investigations have been launched. No one has confronted any accountability for the killing. Like Eygi’s, Abu Akleh’s household has by no means been on the receiving finish of one among Biden’s vaunted meditations on grief. Such shows of empathy are apparently reserved just for the best kind of tragedies.
The parallels don’t finish there. Again in 2022, Abu Akleh’s kinfolk have been granted a gathering with Secretary of State Antony Blinken—one which they later described as largely ineffective. And on Tuesday, Blinken was chosen to answer Eygi’s dying. He was cautious to attend till after the Israeli authorities had launched the outcomes of its personal supposed inquiry. Israel claimed that that Eygi “was hit not directly and unintentionally by IDF fireplace,” and that it had been making an attempt to shoot one other protester, who it stated had been inflicting a “riot.”
Widespread
“swipe left beneath to view extra authors”Swipe →
A number of studies have refuted the declare that there was any type of disturbance going down when Eygi was killed, and “we have been really making an attempt to shoot a special particular person within the head” is hardly probably the most compelling excuse. But it surely was sufficient for Blinken.
Talking at a press convention in London, Blinken referred to as Eygi’s killing “unprovoked and unjustified,” including, “Nobody, nobody must be shot and killed for attending a protest. Nobody ought to must put their life in danger simply to purely categorical their views. The Israeli safety forces must make some basic adjustments in the way in which they function within the West Financial institution, together with adjustments of their guidelines of engagement.”
This looks as if robust speak till you study it extra carefully. Egyi’s dying was “unprovoked and unjustified”—nevertheless it was additionally deliberate. Blinken’s refusal to say so meant that, removed from demanding actual accountability, he wound up endorsing the false narrative that her killing was some terrible blunder, not an intentional assassination. And the concept the Biden administration, which has been bankrolling the genocide in Gaza for almost a yr, goes to do something to pressure Israel to make the adjustments Blinken demanded is fanciful.
Afterward Tuesday, Biden was requested about Eygi. His response was even worse. “Apparently it was an accident, ricocheted off the bottom and simply bought hit by chance. I’m working that out now,” he informed reporters. It might be laborious to think about a extra tone-deaf, checked-out reply.
Ayşenur Eygi was, by all accounts, a devoted organizer, activist, and scholar. Her first identify meant “life and lightweight.” And he or she spent the final moments of that life making an attempt to assist oppressed individuals. In a greater world, she can be exalted by her authorities. As an alternative, america and Israel have collaborated in a tawdry effort to attenuate her dying.
We want your assist
What’s at stake this November is the way forward for our democracy. But Nation readers know the struggle for justice, fairness, and peace doesn’t cease in November. Change doesn’t occur in a single day. We want sustained, fearless journalism to advocate for daring concepts, expose corruption, defend our democracy, safe our bodily rights, promote peace, and defend the setting.
This month, we’re calling on you to present a month-to-month donation to assist The Nation’s unbiased journalism. In the event you’ve learn this far, I do know you worth our journalism that speaks fact to energy in a method corporate-owned media by no means can. The simplest strategy to assist The Nation is by turning into a month-to-month donor; this can present us with a dependable funding base.
Within the coming months, our writers shall be working to deliver you what it’s worthwhile to know—from John Nichols on the election, Elie Mystal on justice and injustice, Chris Lehmann’s reporting from contained in the beltway, Joan Walsh with insightful political evaluation, Jeet Heer’s crackling wit, and Amy Littlefield on the entrance strains of the struggle for abortion entry. For as little as $10 a month, you may empower our devoted writers, editors, and reality checkers to report deeply on probably the most crucial problems with our day.
Arrange a month-to-month recurring donation at this time and be a part of the dedicated neighborhood of readers who make our journalism doable for the lengthy haul. For almost 160 years, The Nation has stood for fact and justice—are you able to assist us thrive for 160 extra?
Onwards,
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editorial Director and Writer, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
At Dartmouth, unions and pro-Palestine activists have developed their causes aspect by aspect round a imaginative and prescient of collective campus liberation.
StudentNation
/
Ramsey Alsheikh
The college’s Gaza Solidarity Encampment led to simply 5 days. However the path to divestment started earlier than the encampment—and stretches far past.
StudentNation
/
Aaron Boehmer
Rabbis for Ceasefire and Hindus for Human Rights make a peace pilgrimage.
Sunita Viswanath
Members of the Blake Road Tenants Union in New Haven see neighborhood possession as crucial to preserving inexpensive housing. Is now the time for widespread tenant management?
StudentNation
/
Maggie Grether
The social gathering could have efficiently prevented Palestinians from addressing the DNC. But it surely can not maintain again the tide perpetually.
Y.L. Al-Sheikh
On this date 54 years in the past, the most important ethnically focussed motion within the motion towards the Vietnam Struggle passed off—providing an vital instance of the ability of a individuals united….
Invoice Gallegos
